Note: the original hard copy of this report is 330 pages .

cover image

By the people, for the people? Community participation in law reform   

, 2010 This study is part of a research program undertaken by the Law and Justice Foundation of New South Wales concerning the access to justice and legal needs of disadvantaged people in New South Wales. The specific aims were to investigate: (1) how law reform in New South Wales occurs; (2) what opportunities and constraints there are for public participation in law reform, directly and through representative bodies; (3) what particular constraints there are for the participation of disadvantaged people in law reform and; (4) the implications of these findings for law reform in New South Wales. Particular attention is paid throughout the report to the participation needs of disadvantaged people and civil society organisations (CSOs).


Access to Justice Advisory Committee 1994, Access to justice: an action plan, AGPS, Canberra.

Alexander, P 2004, ‘Great expectations: in pursuit of legislative reform for boarders in NSW’, Parity, February.

Allen Consulting Group 2003, Shared accommodation for people with a disability: a national competition policy review of the regulation of boarding houses, NSW Department of Ageing, Disability and Home Care, Sydney,

Alt Beatty Consulting 2001, Boarding house reform program — review, NSW Department of Ageing, Disability and Home Care, Sydney.

Anttila, C and Wright, G 2004, Multiple deprivation in New Deal for Communities Areas: applying the Index of Multiple Deprivation 2004 to NDC Areas, New Deal for Communities National Evaluation Data Analysis Paper 28, Social Disadvantage Research Centre, Department of Social Policy and Social Work, University of Oxford, Oxford,

Argy, S and Johnson, M 2003, Mechanisms for improving the quality of regulations: Australia in an international context, Productivity Commission, Melbourne,

Arnstein, S 1971, ‘A ladder of citizen participation’, Journal of the Royal Town Planning Institute, April, pp. 2–6.

Atkinson, J and Olischlager, S 2005, An introduction to the Civil Procedure Act 2005, Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, Attorney General’s Department of NSW, Sydney,

Australian Bureau of Statistics 2008, Adult literacy and life skills survey. Summary results, Australia, 2006 (reissue), ABS Cat. no. 4228.0, Canberra,

Australian Law Reform Commission 2002, Principled regulation: federal civil and administrative penalties in Australia, Report no. 95, Sydney,

Banks, G 2003, ‘The good, the bad and the ugly: economic perspectives on regulation in Australia’, Conference of Economists, Business Symposium, Canberra, 2 October 2003.

Better Regulation Office 2008, Guide to better regulation, NSW Department of Premier and Cabinet, Sydney.

Bishop, P 1999, ‘Representative democracy and the place of participation’, Canberra Bulletin of Public Administration, no. 94, December, pp. 12–16.

Bishop, P and Davis, G 2002, ‘Mapping public participation in policy choices’, Australian Journal of Public Administration, vol. 61, no. 1, March, pp. 14–29.

Blind, PK 2007, ‘Building trust in government in the twenty-first century: review of literature and emerging issues’, Global Forum on Reinventing Government Building Trust in Government, 7th, Vienna, 26–29 June, 2007,

Blue Mountains Community Legal Centre Inc 2000, … Such a long way: the effects of the legal process on the victims of the Glenbrook train accident, Sydney.

Bottomley, S and Parker, S 1997, Law in context, 2nd edn, Federation Press, Sydney.

Brenton, S 2005, Public confidence in Australian democracy, Democratic Audit of Australia, Canberra,

Bridgman, P and Davis, G 2004, The Australian policy handbook, 3rd edn, Allen & Unwin, Sydney.

Brignell, G 2002, Bail: an examination of contemporary issues, Sentencing Trends and Issues no. 24, Judicial Commission of NSW, Sydney,

Brown, D 2002, ‘Sentencing policy: the politics of law and order’, Law Society Journal, vol. 40, no. 9, October, pp. 64–72.

Brown, D 2005, ‘Challenges to criminal justice reform’, in The promise of law reform, eds Opeskin, B and Weisbrot, D, Federation Press, Sydney, pp. 343–357.

Buck, A, Pleasence, P and Balmer, NJ 2007, Education implications from the English and Welsh Civil and Social Justice Survey: annexe to the PLEAS Task Force report, Legal Services Research Centre, London,

Byrne, J and Davis, G 1998, Participation and the NSW policy process: a discussion paper for the Cabinet Office of NSW, NSW Government, Sydney.

Canadian Bar Association 1992, Report of the Canadian Bar Association Task Force on Legal Literacy, Ottawa.

Carson, L and Gelber, K 2001, Ideas for community consultation: a discussion paper on principles and procedures for making consultation work, NSW Department of Urban Affairs and Planning.

Caulfield, J 2000, ‘Public housing and intergovernmental reform in the 1990s’, Australian Journal of Political Science, vol. 35, no. 1, pp. 99–110.

Commonwealth Attorney-General’s Department 1995, The justice statement, Canberra.

Commonwealth Department of Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs 2010, National compact between the Australian Government and Third Sector: consultation report, Canberra,

Community Solutions, Public Interest Advocacy Centre and Environmental Defender’s Office 1995, Public participation in legislative and significant policy processes: a directions document prepared for the Office of Social Policy and the NSW Law Foundation, Sydney.

Coumarelos, C, Wei, Z and Zhou, AZ 2006, ‘Justice made to measure: NSW legal needs survey in disadvantaged areas’, Access to justice and legal needs vol. 3, Law and Justice Foundation of NSW, Sydney,

Council of Canadian Administrative Tribunals 2005, Literacy and access to administrative justice in Canada: a guide for the promotion of plain language, Ottawa,

Council of Social Service of NSW 2004, Briefing paper: basic safeguards are absent in the NSW Government’s legislation to tackle anti social behaviour in public housing estates, Sydney.

Cox, E 1995, A truly civil society, Boyer Lectures 1995, ABC Books, Sydney.

Cranston, R 1987, Law, government and public policy, Oxford University Press, Melbourne.

Da Silva, D 2005, Boarding and lodging houses: a study of the market, law and options for reform in Western Australia, Tenancy Advice Service (Inc) WA and WA Tenancy Network, Perth,

Dalton, B and Lyons, M 2005, Representing the disadvantaged in Australian politics: the role of advocacy organisations, Report no. 5, Democratic Audit of Australia, Australian National University, Canberra,

Davidson, A, Phibbs, P and Cox, G 1998, Inner Sydney boarding house report, University of Sydney, Sydney.

Dearing, JW and Rogers, E 1996, Agenda setting, Sage, London.

Edelman, M 1971, Politics as symbolic action: mass arousal and quiescence, Markham Publishing Company, Chicago.

Everingham, C 1999, ‘Making and breaking the corporatist welfare state: “new left” politics from participation to consultation’, Third Sector Review, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 125–145.

Fair Trading NSW 2009, Navigating the draft Residential Tenancies Bill 2009, Sydney,

Forell, S, McCarron, E and Schetzer, L 2005, No home, no justice? The legal needs of homeless people in NSW, Law and Justice Foundation of NSW, Sydney,

Fung, A and Wright, EO 2003, Deepening democracy: institutional innovations in empowered participatory governance, Verso, London.

Galanter, M 1974, ‘Why the haves come out ahead: speculations on the limits of social change’, Law and Society Review, vol. 9, pp. 95–160.

Galtos, E and Golledge, E 2006, Not such a fine thing! Options for reform of the management of fines matters in NSW, Homeless Persons’ Legal Service, Public Interest Advocacy Centre, Sydney,

Glanfield, L 2005, ‘Law reform through the Executive’, in The promise of law reform, eds Opeskin, B and Weisbrot, D, Federation Press, Sydney, pp. 288–301.

Gleeson, M 2007, The state of the judicature, Australian Legal Convention, 35th, Sydney, 25 March 2007,

Gleeson, M 2008, The meaning of legislation: context, purpose and respect for fundamental rights, Victoria Law Foundation Oration, Melbourne, 31 July, Melbourne.

Gregory, J 2007, Conceptualising consumer engagement: a review of the literature, Working Paper 1 (Revised), Australian Institute of Health Policy Studies, Melbourne,

Griffith, G and Roth, L 2008, Residential tenancy law in NSW, Briefing Paper no. 13/07, NSW Parliamentary Library Research Service, Sydney,

Harrison, V 2005, ‘Lack of rights for city’s boarders’, Reportage Cityside, 30 August.

Hartz-Karp, J 2005, ‘A case study in deliberative democracy: dialogue with the city’, Journal of Public Deliberation, vol. 1, no. 1, Article 6,

Healy, K 2007, Creating better communities: a study of social capital creation in four communities, Benevolent Society, University of Sydney, Sydney,

Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission 1993, Human rights and mental illness: report of the National Inquiry into the Human Rights of People with Mental Illness, Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra.

Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal 2006, Investigation into the burden of regulation in NSW and improving regulatory efficiency: other industries final report, IPART NSW, Sydney,

James, G 2007, Review of the NSW Forensic Mental Health Legislation, NSW Department of Health, Sydney,

Johnston, C 1983, Public access to the legislative process in NSW: a report to the Law Foundation of NSW, Sydney.

Kirby, M 2008, Forty years of the Alberta Law Reform Institute: past, present and future, Alberta Law Reform Institute, Edmonton, Alberta,

Legislation Review Committee 2008, Annual review July 2006–June 2007, Report no. 2, NSW Parliament, Sydney,

Legislation Review Committee 2009, Annual review 2007/2008, Report no. 3, NSW Parliament, Sydney,

Legislative Council Select Committee on Mental Health 2002, Inquiry into mental health services in NSW: final report, Parliamentary Paper: no 368, Parliament of NSW, Sydney,

Lindsay, G 2005, Dynamics of the civil procedure regime in NSW, Delivered as part of the University of New South Wales CLE program on 3 March, Sydney.

Macdonald, RA 2001, ‘Access to justice and law reform #2’, Windsor Yearbook of Access to Justice, vol. 19, pp. 317–325.

Macdonald, RA 2005, ‘Access to justice in Canada today: scope, scale, ambitions’, in Access to justice for a new century: the way forward, eds Bass, J, Bogart, W and Zemans, F, Law Society of Upper Canada, Ontario, pp. 19–112.

Maddisson, S, Denniss, R and Hamilton, C 2004, Silencing dissent: non-government organizations and Australian democracy, Discussion Paper no. 65, Australia Institute, Canberra.

Marien, M and Hickey, J 2002, Bail Amendment (Repeat Offenders) Bill 2002, Crisis in Bail and Remand Seminar, 29 May, Sydney.

Martin, C 2004, ‘Law and order in public housing: the Residential Tenancies Amendment (Public Housing) Act 2004 (NSW)’, Current Issues in Criminal Justice, vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 226–232.

McHugh, MH 1995, ‘The growth of legislation and litigation’, Australian Law Journal, vol. 69, January, pp. 37–48.

McKeown, D, Lundie, R and Baker, G 2005, Crossing the floor in the Federal Parliament 1950–August 2004, Research Note no. 11, Parliamentary Library, Canberra,

Melville, R and Perkins, R 2003, Changing roles of community-sector peak bodies in a neo-liberal policy environment in Australia. An ARC funded study (2000–2002) final report, Institute of Social Change and Critical Inquiry, Faculty of Arts, University of Wollongong, Wollongong.

Mental Health Coordinating Council 2005, ‘Improved attitude to “acceptable behaviour agreements” achieved’, View from the Peak, Summer, p. 5,

Mowbray, RC 1989, Lost in the law: tenancy law reform for boarders and lodgers. A report to the State Executive of the Combined Pensioners’ Association of NSW, Combined Pensioners’ Association of NSW Inc, Sydney.

National Shelter 1996, Working paper produced by National Shelter as part of the AHURI Private Rental Research Project.

Newtown Neighbourhood Centre 2003, Opening these doors: boarders and lodgers report into the conditions and residents of unlicensed boarding houses in the Marrickville LGA, NSW Department of Ageing Disability and Home Care, Sydney.

NSW Department of Community Services and Forum of Non-Government Agencies 2006, Working together for NSW: an agreement between the NSW Government and NSW non-government human services organisations, Sydney,

NSW Department of Housing 2004, Information sheet: Antisocial behaviour, Sydney.

NSW Department of Housing 2005, NSW Government antisocial behaviour strategy, Sydney.

NSW Department of Housing 2007, Good neighbour policy - EST0013A, Sydney.

NSW Health 2004, Review of the Mental Health Act 1990. Discussion paper 2: the Mental Health Act 1990, Sydney.

NSW Health 2006, Review of the Mental Health Act 1990: report, Sydney,

NSW Law Reform Commission 1996, People with an intellectual disability and the criminal justice system, Report no. 80, Sydney,

NSW Law Reform Commission 1998, Review of the Disability Services Act 1993 (NSW), Issues Paper 16, Sydney,

NSW Law Reform Commission 1999, Review of the Disability Services Act 1993 (NSW), Report 91, Sydney,

NSW Law Reform Commission 2000, Evaluation of the NSW Law Reform Commission’s consultation processes in the review of the DSA and CAMA, Sydney,

NSW Mental Health Sentinel Events Review Committee 2003, Tracking tragedy: first report of the Committee, NSW Health, Sydney.

NSW Ombudsman 2006, DADHC: Monitoring standards in boarding houses. A special report to Parliament under s 31 of the Ombudsman Act 1974, Sydney,

Office of Regulation Review 1998, A guide to regulation, 2nd edn, Canberra,

Opeskin, B 2002, ‘Engaging the public: community participation in the genetic information inquiry’, Reform: a Journal of National and International Law Reform, vol. 80, pp. 53–59.

Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development 2001, Engaging citizens in policy making: information, consultation and public participation, PUMA Policy Brief no.10,

Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development 2002, Regulatory policies in OECD countries: from interventionism to regulatory governance, OECD Publishing, Paris.

Parliamentary Counsel’s Office 2000, Manual for the preparation of legislation, 8th edn, NSW Government, Sydney,

Parliamentary Counsel’s Office 2007, Manual for the drafting of non-government legislation, 8th edn, NSW Government, Sydney,

Pateman, C 1970, Participation and democratic theory, University Press, Cambridge.

Peterson, M 2001, ‘From trust to political power: interest groups, public choice and health care’, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, vol. 26, no. 5, October, pp. 1145–1163.

Power, C and Mott, P 2003, ‘A tale of two cities: legal protection for rooming/boarding house residents in Victoria and NSW’, Flinders Journal of Law Reform, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 137–153.

Property Owners’ Association of NSW 2009, What is a boarding house? How are they different to residential tenancies, Sydney,

Public Accounts Committee 2002, Inquiry into court waiting times, Report no.133, NSW Parliament Legislative Assembly, Sydney,

Public Interest Advocacy Centre 2003, Working the system: a guide for citizens, consumers and communities, Sydney.

Rawsthorne, M and Christian, F 2004, Making it meaningful: government/community sector relations, Research Report, Western Sydney Community Forum, Sydney,

Regulatory Review Unit Cabinet Office 1995, From red tape to results. Government regulation: a guide to best practice, Sydney.

Robeyns, I 2003, The capability approach: an interdisciplinary introduction, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam,

Ross, S 1982, Politics of law reform, Penguin Books Australia, Ringwood, Victoria.

Sackville, R 1975, Law and poverty in Australia, Australian Government Commission of Inquiry into Poverty, Second Main Report, AGPS, Canberra.

Sawer, G 1976, ‘Who controls the law in Australia? Instigators of change and the obstacles confronting them’, in Australian lawyers and social change: proceedings of a seminar held at the Faculty of Law, Australian National University, 23–25 August 1974, eds Hambley, D and Goldring, D, Law Book Company, Sydney, pp. 118–182.

Schetzer, L and Henderson, J 2003, Public consultations: a project to identify legal needs, pathways and barriers for disadvantaged people in NSW, Access to Justice and Legal Needs vol. 1, Law and Justice Foundation of NSW, Sydney,

Sen, A 1999, Development as freedom, Alfred A Knopf, New York.

Serr, K 2004, ‘Voices from the bottom’, Australian Social Work, vol. 57, no. 2, June, pp. 137–149.

Shelter NSW 1999, Submission to the Boarders and Lodgers Review, Sydney, NSW.

Singleton, G, Aitkin, D, Jinks, B and Warhurst, J 2003, Australian political institutions, 7th edn, Longman, Sydney.

Skotnicki, T 2005, ‘Last roll of the dice’, Business Review Weekly, 30 June.

Spigelman, J 2005, ‘Foreword’, in Ritchie’s uniform civil procedure NSW, eds Taylor, P, Elms, E, Bellew G and Meek, M, LexisNexis Butterworths, Sydney, pp. 5–6.

Tenants’ Union of NSW 2004, Rights for boarders now! You can do something about it, Sydney.

Tenants’ Union of NSW 2005, Occupancy rights for residents of licensed residential centres: a briefing paper, Sydney,

Tomasic, R 1980, ‘The sociology of legislation’, in Legislation and society in Australia, ed. Tomasic, R, Law Foundation of NSW and George Allen & Unwin, Sydney, pp. 19–49.

Twomey, A and Wilkins, R nd, Cabinet conventions: NSW practice, Department of Premier and Cabinet, Sydney,

Watchirs, H 2005, ‘The ACT Human Rights Act 2004: a new scrutiny challenge’, Australasian and Pacific Conference on Delegated Legislation, 9th, and Australasian and Pacific Conference on the Scrutiny of Bills, Legislative Assembly for the ACT, 6th, 2 March 2005, Canberra,

Weatherburn, D 2004, Law and order in Australia: rhetoric and reality, Federation Press, Sydney.

Wilkinson, B 2003, ‘Evaluating government regulations’, Agenda, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 325–339,

Woolcock, M 1998, ‘Social capital and economic development: toward a theoretical synthesis and policy framework’, Theory and Society, vol. 27, no. 2, April, pp. 151–208.

Woolcock, M and Narayan, D 2000, ‘Social capital: implications for development theory, research, and policy’, World Bank Research Observer, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 225–249,

World Economic Forum 2002, Trust will be the challenge of 2003: poll reveals a lack of trust in all institutions, including democratic institutions, large companies, NGOs and media across the world. Press release, Geneva,

Yin, RK 1994, Case study research: design and methods, 2nd edn, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, California.